Cedar shake roofs cost $8–$14 per sq. ft., while asphalt shingles range from $3–$7 per sq. ft. Cedar shake costs more because of the premium wood material and skilled labour required, but they offer greater longevity and visual appeal. Asphalt shingles are budget-friendly, easier to install, and require less upkeep, making them a popular choice for residential roofing.
Synthetic cedar shakes provide a middle ground: lower maintenance, improved fire resistance, and still offer the cedar look.
The Base Cost: Cedar Shakes vs Asphalt Shingles
Start with raw numbers. Costs vary by region, but here’s a general breakdown:
- 3-tab asphalt shingles: $90–$120 per square (100 sq. ft.)
- Architectural shingles: $110–$140 per square
- Cedar shakes: $300–$600 per square
Cedar roofing uses natural materials like Western Red Cedar. These shakes are often hand-split, making them more expensive than mass-produced fibreglass-based asphalt shingles.
Installation Labor: Who Charges More and Why
Cedar shake roof installation is labor-intensive. It needs expert installers, felt underlayments, attic ventilation, and sometimes fire-retardant treatment. Labor alone can cost $400–$900 per square.
Asphalt shingle roofing is faster and more familiar to contractors. Labor usually costs $150–$350 per square.
So, cedar roofing may cost 2–3 times more just in labor.
Full Roof Replacement Costs: Real Numbers
For a 2,000 sq. ft. roof:
- Asphalt shingles: $6,000–$10,000
- Cedar shakes: $16,000–$30,000
- Synthetic cedar shakes: $10,000–$20,000
If you’re considering reroofing, keep synthetic options like CeDUR and Brava in mind.
What Are You Paying For? Aesthetics, Durability, and More
Curb Appeal & Aesthetic Value
Cedar shake roofs add rustic charm and custom appeal, perfect for upscale or historic homes. Architectural shingles mimic this look, but they don’t fully replicate the texture and depth of real wood.
Longevity & Maintenance
- Cedar shakes: 30–50 years with regular roof maintenance
- Asphalt shingles: 15–30 years with little maintenance
- Synthetic shakes: Long-lasting with minimal upkeep
Cedar shake repairs often include mold/algae removal and re-oiling.
Fire Resistance Ratings
- Asphalt shingles: Class A fire rating
- Untreated cedar: Class C or lower
- Treated cedar & synthetic shakes: Can reach Class A
In wildfire-prone areas, fire rating impacts insurance coverage. Synthetic shakes from Brava or CeDUR are fire-rated out of the box.
Impact Resistance and Weather Durability
- Asphalt shingles can be rated Class 4, great for hail zones.
- Cedar shakes offer decent impact resistance but can split.
- Synthetic roofing systems resist UV, moisture, and extreme temperatures better than natural wood.
Environmental Impact & Roofing Sustainability
- Cedar is natural but may not be sustainable unless FSC-certified.
- Asphalt is petroleum-based and often non-recyclable.
- Synthetic shingles vary, some brands use recycled materials.
For greener options, you could also explore metal roofing or clay tile roofs.
Energy Efficiency and Utility Savings
- Cedar shakes: decent insulation value
- Asphalt shingles: may trap heat unless coated
- Synthetic shakes: designed for energy efficiency
Square Footage and Cost Per Square Foot Breakdown
| Material | Avg Cost per Sq Ft Installed | Approx. Cost for 2,000 sq ft |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt shingles | $4.00 – $12.25 | $8,000 – $24,500 |
| Cedar shake roofing | $25.00 – $30.00 | $50,000 – $60,000 |
| Synthetic cedar shakes | $5.00 – $10.00 | $10,000 – $20,000 |
Tip: Don’t forget accessories like gutters, drip edge, and underlayment.
Long-Term Value: Lifespan, Warranty & Resale
Asphalt Shingles
- Lifespan: 15–30 years
- Warranty: Often lifetime on materials
- Fire rating: Class A
- Insurance: Typically lower premiums
Cedar Shake Roofing
- Lifespan: 30–50 years
- Warranty: Workmanship coverage only
- Fire rating: Class C unless treated
- Resale: Boosts appeal in upscale neighborhoods
When You Might Choose One Over the Other
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
- You’re budget-conscious
- You need a quick installation
- You live in an HOA-restricted area
- You’re in a snow or hail-heavy zone
Choose Cedar Shake If:
- You want upscale curb appeal
- You’re in a historic district
- You prefer natural materials
- You’re okay with more maintenance
Go with Synthetic Cedar Shake If:
- You love the cedar look but hate the upkeep
- You live in a wildfire zone
- You want strong warranties and a long-term solution
FAQ
Do cedar shakes outlast asphalt shingles in terms of lifespan?
Yes, cedar shakes last 25–35 years with upkeep, while standard asphalt shingles last 15–25 years.
Is it difficult to get insurance for a cedar shake roof?
Yes, many insurers charge more or deny coverage unless the shakes are fire-treated.
Why does cedar shake roof replacement cost more than asphalt?
It requires skilled labor, takes more time, and materials are harder to source.
How frequently should a cedar shake roof be replaced?
Every 25–30 years, depending on climate and maintenance level.
Final Word from a Roofing Pro
People see the price tag and panic. But roofing isn’t just a bill, it’s an investment. Between your roofing system, ventilation, gutter setup, and Wisconsin’s ever-changing weather, it pays to think long-term.
At Northern Generations Roofing, we’ve seen what works. If you’re torn between cedar shakes and asphalt shingles, talk to our team. We don’t do hard sells. We build roofs that last. We are located at 6326 W Bluemound Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53213, United States. Visit our office. Get direction.
