You don’t always need a full roof replacement. But when you do, ignoring it is a mistake that gets more expensive fast. Here are five signs that mean you probably need a new roof and why you shouldn’t wait around when you see them.
1. Shingles Are Curling, Cracking, or Just Missing
Look up at your roof. If you see shingles that are curled up at the edges, cracked in half, or worse, just not there anymore, you’ve got a problem. It’s not just cosmetic. Missing or damaged shingles mean the waterproofing is failing, and water’s getting in somewhere. People think, “Eh, I’ll replace a few,” and that works sometimes. But if your roof’s got spots all over or repairs keep popping up every year, it’s time to stop patching and replace it. Shingle roofs usually last 20-25 years. If you’re getting close to that and seeing damage, you’re on borrowed time.
Common mistake:
Waiting too long. By the time interior leaks show up, there’s usually rot under the shingle,s and that means you’re paying for woodwork too, not just new shingles.
2. Granules in Your Gutters or Around the Downspouts
Granules are those tiny bits on top of asphalt shingles. They protect against UV and weather damage. When your roof’s nearing the end, the granules start shedding like crazy. You’ll notice gritty debris piling up in gutters or around your downspouts. That means the shingles are getting thin and weak.
Why it matters:
Once the granules are gone, your shingles are exposed. The Sun breaks them down faster. Water can seep in more easily. And everything underneath is at risk.
What we do:
When we inspect a roof and see granule loss, we check how widespread it is. If it’s uniform and consistent across large sections, we recommend replacement not because we want the job, but because it’s the right move for long-term protection.
3. Leaks, Stains, or Sagging on the Interior
If you’ve got water stains on your ceiling, that’s not just from “a small leak.” That’s from repeated, prolonged water intrusion. You might not see the drip, but the damage is building up behind your drywall, in your insulation, maybe even in your attic structure. learn more about roof leaks.
Sagging? That’s structural. Call us immediately. That’s not optional.
What happens if you ignore it:
Mold, rot, and higher energy bills from ruined insulation. Eventually, you’ll end up ripping out whole sections of the ceiling or drywall in addition to replacing the roof. And now the project costs double or triple.
Mistakes people make:
Hiring someone to just fix the ceiling stain without checking the roof. The problem isn’t inside; it started outside.
4. Your Roof Is Just Old
This one’s boring but important. Age alone can be a reason to replace your roof, even if it “looks fine.” Most homeowners don’t know exactly when the roof was installed, especially if they bought the house secondhand. Shingles might still be on, but they’re brittle, sealed poorly, or warped in ways that aren’t visible unless you’re up there.
Reality check:
If your roof is 20+ years old, it’s at the end of its designed lifespan. Even if it’s not leaking now, it’s not doing its job as efficiently. Heat escapes. Moisture lingers. And any small issue can quickly snowball.
What we look for:
On an older roof, we check flashing, valleys, and ridge vents closely. If multiple components are degraded, that’s a sign the system as a whole is done.
5. You’ve Had Major Storm Damage or Poor Installations
Sometimes we see roofs that are “newer” but still need to be replaced. Why? Storm damage or bad installs. Hail can destroy shingles in one afternoon. So can heavy wind. Poor installations, wrong nails, skipped flashing, and bad ventilation might not show issues right away, but give it 2–3 years, and the whole thing’s failing.
Big mistake here:
Assuming insurance will always cover it. They won’t if it’s wear and tear or faulty workmanship. So homeowners put off fixing it, thinking it’s someone else’s problem. Meanwhile, the structure’s getting worse.
How we approach this:
We’re certified and licensed, and we know what to look for in signs of improper nailing, ventilation issues, or manufacturer defects. If we think your roof has a claimable issue, we’ll guide you through that too. But we’re not gonna sugarcoat it if it just needs to be replaced. Better to do it once and do it right.
Bottom Line
Roof problems don’t fix themselves. We’ve been doing this for a long time in Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wauwatosa, all over. We’ve seen what happens when homeowners wait too long, trust the wrong crew, or don’t understand what’s going on with their roof. If you’ve seen any of the signs above, reach out. We’ll inspect it. We’ll tell you straight. No pressure, no gimmicks.
Call Northern Generations Construction. We’re local, licensed, and show up and get it done right.
Read Our Roofing Blog & Pro-Tips
How to check for roof leaks
Signs Of A Roof Leak In The Attic
How to fix loose roof shingles
Residential roof inspection
house roof inspection
Apartment roof inspection
